Search
Filters
Close

Save 20% on select titles with code HIDDEN24 - Shop The Sale Now

Hydrogen Embrittlement Failure Of Nickel Alloy UNS N07716-140 Tubing Retrievable Safety Valve Component Installed In A Sour Production Gas Well

A 9-5/8 inch (244.8 mm) Tubing Retrievable Safety Valve (TRSV), which is a type of Sub Surface Safety Valve (SSSV) governed by API Specification 14A, was found to have failed when retrieved during workover operations in a gas production well in June 2019. This TRSV was installed in the well in November 2013 and was in production service from 2015 until November 2018 when the well was shut in for maintenance of surface equipment. In March 2019, with the well still shut in for maintenance, a rapid increase in the tubing-casing annulus (TCA) pressure was observed.

Product Number: 51322-17709-SG
Author: Iyad Al-Buraiki, Qasem Alhassan, Karthik Krishnan, Wade Meaders
Publication Date: 2022
$0.00
$20.00
$20.00

A failure in a Precipitation Hardened (PH) Nickel alloy component used as part of a Tubing Retrievable Safety Valve (TRSV) assembly occurred in an offshore gas well. The partial pressures of H2S and CO2 at the TRSV were estimated to be 333 and 534 psia, respectively. The well also produced 0.1 lb/MMSCF of elemental sulfur. The failed component was manufactured using grade UNS N07716 PH Nickel alloy heat treated to 140 ksi (965 MPa) Specified Minimum Yield Strength (SMYS) and 43 HRC max hardness in compliance to NACE MR0175/ISO 15156-3 standard.1 The well was completed and had been in production for approximately five years with no major issues before it was shut-in to service wellhead equipment. A few months after shut-in of the well for service, a rapid increase in the tubing-casing annulus (TCA) pressure was observed which resulted in the need to workover the downhole completion. During workover operations, the TRSV was found to have parted at a major body component of the TRSV assembly, resulting in only the upper portion of the Top Sub being initially retrieved. Fishing operations later successfully retrieved the remainder of the TRSV. Failure analysis of the component indicated brittle fracture due to Hydrogen Embrittlement (HE) as the cause of the failure. The failure initiated at a high stress location in a box thread of the component and propagated through the component’s cross-section resulting in complete separation of the component into two portions. This paper provides the details of the environment conditions, analysis of the failed component, including metallurgical and engineering analysis, and results of HE testing conducted as part of analysis.

A failure in a Precipitation Hardened (PH) Nickel alloy component used as part of a Tubing Retrievable Safety Valve (TRSV) assembly occurred in an offshore gas well. The partial pressures of H2S and CO2 at the TRSV were estimated to be 333 and 534 psia, respectively. The well also produced 0.1 lb/MMSCF of elemental sulfur. The failed component was manufactured using grade UNS N07716 PH Nickel alloy heat treated to 140 ksi (965 MPa) Specified Minimum Yield Strength (SMYS) and 43 HRC max hardness in compliance to NACE MR0175/ISO 15156-3 standard.1 The well was completed and had been in production for approximately five years with no major issues before it was shut-in to service wellhead equipment. A few months after shut-in of the well for service, a rapid increase in the tubing-casing annulus (TCA) pressure was observed which resulted in the need to workover the downhole completion. During workover operations, the TRSV was found to have parted at a major body component of the TRSV assembly, resulting in only the upper portion of the Top Sub being initially retrieved. Fishing operations later successfully retrieved the remainder of the TRSV. Failure analysis of the component indicated brittle fracture due to Hydrogen Embrittlement (HE) as the cause of the failure. The failure initiated at a high stress location in a box thread of the component and propagated through the component’s cross-section resulting in complete separation of the component into two portions. This paper provides the details of the environment conditions, analysis of the failed component, including metallurgical and engineering analysis, and results of HE testing conducted as part of analysis.

Also Purchased
Picture for On the Susceptibility of Precipitation Hardened Nickel Alloys to Hydrogen Assisted Cracking
Available for download

On the Susceptibility of Precipitation Hardened Nickel Alloys to Hydrogen Assisted Cracking

Product Number: 51319-12846-SG
Author: Roberto Morana
Publication Date: 2019
$20.00
Picture for UNS N07725 NICKEL ALLOY CONNECTION FAILURE
Available for download

51312-01095-UNS N07725 NICKEL ALLOY CONNECTION FAILURE

Product Number: 51312-01095-SG
ISBN: 01095 2012 CP
Author: Steve S. Shademan
Publication Date: 2012
$20.00